Review: Three Ships 5 Year Old Premium Select Whisky

Three Ships 5 Year OldThree Ships Whisky is produced at James Sedgewick Distillery, in Wellington, South Africa. It’s the only South African whisky I’ve tasted, and it caught my eye because won some great awards at the IWSC and the WWA…the malt and the grain are distilled separately  – the malt whisky in a copper pot still and the grain whisky in a continuous column still, and then combined and aged. The whiskies are aged separately and then combined, a bit like 40 Creek. This 5 year old version has a blend of both South African and Scotch Whisky.

Nose: what a nose! Strong peaty character, with rich caramel and fruit – pear dominates. There’s also a bit of sour apple, likely a combination of the fruitiness and some of the sourness from the grains which are lingering in the background. Also present are vanilla, of a slightly creamy sort – almost like over-whipped cream. There are also slight spices….The nose makes me want to jump right into tasting, without even giving the nose a full appreciation. The peat is quite present and bold, yet controlled and integrated into the rest of the nose beautifully. 28/30 (93%)

Taste: sweet start before the flavour ramps up, with the mouth heating as the peat gets bigger and becomes integrated into some oak spice. The fruitiness is integrated as well, as apples and pears appear, and dominate more as your mouth becomes accustomed to the peat. Finishes with some spice and heat – white pepper and cinnamon- before the peat fades, and then the fruit remains. It’s sweet, rich, full…superb.

Usually, before my tastings, I condition my palate with black coffee (as per the suggestion of Jim Murray, which I have almost always followed before serious reviews ever since I heard it). However, during one of my tastings I had ice cream before -which resulted in less enjoyment of the whisky as the sweetness was sapped out – but it made me realize that the whisky, was, in fact, slightly salty. During my subsequent tasting the saltiness was also unmistakeable, which was an unexpected twist for me as I did not expect it. The other interesting thing is that there is a bit of a sour character, almost like lemon, which tugs at the inside of your mouth. The whisky leaves the mouth with a bit more peat and a touch of oak tannin. Overall, it’s a great taste, although as I’ve drunk more I have wished for a touch more depth. 25.5/30 (85.5%)

Finish: the heat dies down, the peat fades, and I am left with more of a fruity than a peaty character, contrary to what I expected. However, the fruit soon fades and remaining is nice peat lingering in your mouth. The finish is certainly evident in the mouth…chewable and enduring. I also love finishes that seem almost to cleanse the mouth once you’ve tasted the whisky, as this one does. 18.5/20 (93%)

Conclusion: I saw this whisky come in at the liquor store, and decided to grab a bottle as I had heard about some of its accolades. All my hopes were confirmed iIMG_0731n the nose…

I do my best to not let price influence my ratings. For $35, in Ontario, this is quite the bargain. What is more, despite the price it’s still bottled at 43% rather than 40%, of which I certainly approve. Certainly worth a dram or two! 17/20 (85%)

Overall: 89/100


6 thoughts on “Review: Three Ships 5 Year Old Premium Select Whisky

  1. Hi James,
    Nice review! I had a taste of this Three Ships release at The Spirit of Toronto in May 2014… although it was near the end of the evening and my palate was somewhat overwhelmed, I do recall that this was a very easy drinking dram.

    I am a member on the WhiskyConnosr network ( On a recent discussion thread on younger whiskies (less than 9 years old), I mentioned this whisky as one to try, and while scanning for additional information on it I found your blog entry. I hope you blog from WhiskyConnosr….

    Sláinte Mhaith!

    Tom Fahey
    Elmira, ON

  2. oops… meant to say “I hope you don’t mind that I placed a link to your blog from WhiskyConnosr” and not “I hope you blog from Whisky Connosr”


  3. Alcohol comes through harsh,peat is to much for me, finish falls apart and not really there,let the glass sit for awhile it mellowed out but this scotch is just not for me.

    Drank straight up,maybe water would help but I don’t use it.

  4. What a nose! I thought I was drinking aniseptic. The taste wasn’t that bad but I couldn’t get over the smell.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s