Review: Whistlepig 10 Year Old Straight Rye Whisky

Whistlepig 1 This whisky is somewhat notorious for trying to disguise both the source of its origin (Canada), and the fact that they don’t actually distill any of their product (yet). If you go hunting on the label, on the back, in the corner, is a small little statement “imported from Canada”. Dave Pickerell, the former master distiller at Maker’s Mark, a well known whisky consultant who has a love for rye, is at the helm of the Whistlepig operation – and this product has been a huge success. The hope of the Whistlepig farm (in Vermont) is to do a complete seed to glass process, growing their own rye, distilling it, and aging it. It’s a pretty neat vision. For now, however, none of their product is self-produced and has come from Canada – though that might change soon as they have now say they have some other sources.

This whisky is sourced from Alberta Distillers, like some other successful and excellent whiskies such as Masterson’s Rye. It is made from 100% rye, unmalted, I believe – and, as the Alberta distillery does – this likely went in the barrel just short of 80% ABV, and came out likely above 80% before dilution. This shows the quality of the stuff that goes into the blends in Canada – typically a process with a “base” whisky which provides the bulk of the body and profile, and then this is “flavoured” with a stronger, perhaps spicier, whisky such as this one. I wish, among many others, that these flavouring ryes would be released because of their incredible quality…but sadly most of them are not.

While it’s true that Canada largely keeps the best of its whisky to itself, in this case it’s not true. In Ontario, this bottle can’t be found and hasn’t ever been around, as far as I know (I picked mine up in Boston).

Nose: Oak, and rye – simple, and beautiful – strong off the nose, with some wonderful earthiness too. Caramel, orange, a bit of arugula…a very similar style to masterson’s. Lots going on – vanilla starts to emerge, with some canola oil, tabacco, caramel, mint chocolate, star anise, a touch of smoke, and butterscotch – quite a wonderful and wide array of buttery and caramel notes. A bit of fruit, but it’s not overly fruity – cherry notes are present. A few odd notes start to come out with time, which I don’t like much – reminding me of ketchup chips (quite unlike anything else I’ve nosed). But, overall, quite good. 26/30 (87%)

Taste: Fairly sweet, with a sharp arugula-laced rye body (the arugula is interesting – I find it strongly here, in Masterson’s, and in the Collingwood 21 Year old – all 100% ryes). There is a nice oaky underlying spice explosion (white pepper and cinnamon)- this is very, very enjoyable, and oak takes over towards the end. There is vanilla, too, wonderfully balanced in the palate. And, with all that, there are some nice, bright, floral notes hinting of lilac. 26.5/30 (88%)

Finish: Marmelade, caramel, black currant jam, cinnamon, and a bit of dry oak….and our arugula. It grows as you drink more, with more spice (cayenne pepper, clove) and more fruit (I find green apple comes out)…and then woody notes like cedar start to appear. Very good body, spiciness, and sweetness. 18.5/20 (93%)

Conclusion: This is very good. To be honest, it’s surprising to me how much it reminded me of Masterson’s, but I am not suprised – they are both independently bottled from the same recipe and age of the same dWhistlepig 2istillery. Whistlepig, though, is less intense – a bit woodier, and, perhaps darker – but less spicy, sharp, and refined with a bit less complexity and development. All that said – Masterson’s is among the best, and Whistlepig is still very good. This bottle will have no difficulty being consumed. 17.5/20 (88%)

Overall Score: 88.5/100


4 thoughts on “Review: Whistlepig 10 Year Old Straight Rye Whisky

  1. Pingback: Review: Jefferson’s Straight Rye Whiskey Aged 10 Years | Whisky Won

  2. Pingback: Review: Alberta Premium 25 Year Old Canadian Rye Whisky | Whisky Won

  3. Pingback: Review: Gooderham & Worts Canadian Whisky | Whisky Won

  4. Pingback: Review: Pendleton 1910 Aged 12 Years Canadian Rye Whisky | Whisky Won

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s